Our analysts share insights on the best and worst transfer activities during the recent window, highlighting significant signings and overall performances of various clubs.
Which three clubs excelled in the transfer market and why?
Alex Keble: Brighton, West Ham, Manchester United
Brighton & Hove Albion's investment of £200 million in new players has brought in many promising talents, allowing manager Fabian Hurzeler to build a competitive squad. New wingers Yankuba Minteh and Brajan Gruda, along with midfielders Mats Wieffer and Matt O’Riley, are set to enhance the team's performance. Additionally, Ferdi Kadioglu and Georginio Rutter are expected to develop into key contributors.
West Ham United made notable additions, including Aaron Wan-Bissaka, Crysencio Summerville, and Maximilian Kilman, though the signing of 31-year-old Niclas Fullkrug might not address the team's central-forward needs. Despite a rocky start to the season, Manchester United's new management at INEOS deserves recognition for their effective player sales and smart acquisitions like Leny Yoro, Joshua Zirkzee, and Noussair Mazraoui.
Adrian Clarke: Brighton, West Ham, Ipswich
Brighton's transfer strategy has significantly strengthened their squad depth and quality. Kadioglu showcased his talent at the Euros, while Minteh has quickly become a valuable asset. The signing of midfielder Wieffer for around £25 million could prove to be a steal, enhancing Brighton's chances this season. West Ham’s roster has also improved, with the additions of Wan-Bissaka, Kilman, and Jean-Clair Todibo, all seen as upgrades, alongside Fullkrug’s arrival boosting team morale.
Kieran McKenna has focused on young talent at Ipswich Town, bringing in promising players like Liam Delap and Jack Clarke. If they adapt well to the Premier League, Ipswich could secure their top-flight status.
Adrian Kajumba: West Ham, Manchester United, Crystal Palace
West Ham has made several strategic signings, allowing new coach Lopetegui to field a revamped team without losing key players. Although results have been mixed, there are signs of progress. Manchester United's five key signings, including Zirkzee and Yoro, have addressed important positions and freshened up the squad. Crystal Palace's transfer window, while marked by the loss of Michael Olise, also saw them bolster their squad with effective replacements.
Ben Bloom: Brighton, Tottenham, West Ham
Brighton's significant spending this summer is expected to pay off, with Minteh emerging as a standout signing among a depth-filled roster. Tottenham's investment in Dominic Solanke to replace Harry Kane appears promising, alongside their new teenage midfielders, which bode well for the future. West Ham has notably enhanced their squad depth and made key defensive upgrades.
Which three clubs had the least successful transfer window and why?
Ben Bloom: Newcastle, Wolves, Everton
Despite retaining some key players, Newcastle manager Howe expressed disappointment over a transfer window he described as unsatisfactory. Their failure to secure defender Guehi and the lack of improvements to the starting lineup were significant concerns. Wolves' head coach O’Neil acknowledged that their transfer strategy fell short after losing crucial players, although they did bring in intriguing prospects like Rodrigo Gomes. Everton faced challenges due to ownership issues, limiting their ability to pursue major signings and forcing a focus on developing future talent.